case studies of a single region and ethnic group and it
was not able to prove the universality of the
phenomenon.
Zhang Haibo (2015)'s empirical research based on
Jiangsu Province emphasized that although the rural
emergency management ability and villagers' self-
rescue and mutual rescue level have been advanced in
the short term, the progress of disaster prevention and
reduction level still needs long-term investment under
the policy suggestions. Zhang Yongli and Liu Xingsi
(2024) discussed the specific implementation of local
emergency management policies from the
perspective of institutional change and pointed out
that the differences in policy implementation are
mainly due to the poor understanding of policy texts
by local governments. The mismatch between the
policy implementation process and the rural social
environment results in poor policy implementation in
the process of rural emergency management. The
complexity of policy implementation often leads to
different understandings of policy implementation by
stakeholders, which results in poor execution.
Nonetheless, the study did not provide a detailed
analysis of specific differences in policy
implementation failures between rural and urban
areas, which may limit the applicability of the
findings to some extent. Fu Jinhua (2021)'s research
analyzed the optimization path of rural emergency
management policy from the perspective of "one plan
and three systems". It is proposed to be closely
integrated with the rural revitalization strategy,
strengthen institutional "top-level design" with a
focus on prevention and mitigation to improve policy
implementation mechanisms. In addition to this, Xu
Yuanshan (2015) believed that China urgently needs
to promote the "bottom-level design" of rural
emergency management to refine the disaster
prevention and mitigation capacity of rural
communities. Although both studies put forward
ideas for rural emergency management from the
perspective of the policy framework, they ignored the
realistic dilemma at the level of policy
implementation as well.
Different from the institutional analysis of Zhang
Yongli and Fu Jinhua, Wu Wei (2020)'s research
focuses on governance optimization at the practical
level, which believes that the network governance
model can effectively heighten the ability of rural
communities to manage emergencies. The
importance of grass-roots staff and villagers
participating in fire management is emphasized as
well. However, the study mainly analyzed the role of
network management from a theoretical perspective;
the implementation of specific policies was not
analyzed and the realistic difficulties in policy
implementation did not been fully explored and
followed up. By contrast, Wang Wenbo (2016)'s
research focused on electrical fires in rural areas of
southwest China, which emphasized the high
incidence of fire caused by backward circuit, private
wiring and excessive power load. Recommendations
were made to ameliorate local fire prevention,
suppression and rescue efforts as well. However, the
study was limited to the southwest, which leads to a
lack of national or regional comparative analysis of
this research question and limits the generality of the
findings to some extent. Similar to Wang's study,
Peng et al. (2016) also focused on fire safety in rural
areas of southwest China. But still, the research
emphasized the optimization of fire safety
management systems and concrete solutions such as
grid management and increasing financial support is
proposed. Nevertheless, the scope of the data
collected by the institute was limited, only six villages
in three provinces were involved, and a total of 76
questionnaires were collected. As a result, the
representativeness and credibility of the research
conclusions need to be verified. On top of that, the
present situation of fire safety and the difficulties of
fire prevention and control in rural areas of Guizhou
and Guangdong were analyzed from a professional
perspective by Bu Hongbo (2016) and Li Jingming
(2014) as the grass-roots fire team staff. Zhang
Mingcan (2016) also took grass-roots practice as the
starting point and put forward the contradiction
between urban-rural integration and the shortage of
rural fire resources. Nonetheless, their research also
lacked guidance and advanced measures at the policy
level.
4 DISCUSSION
Existing research has made important contributions to
fire emergency management policies in rural areas.
Some studies revealed the main causes, existing
characteristics and structural problems behind rural
fires through empirical investigation and data
analysis. Some of the research focused on the level of
policy, systematically combed the development vein
of China's rural fire protection policy, summarized
the main measures of the governments' rural fire
protection policy in recent years, and analyzed the
main contents of the policy, the effect of
implementation and the difference of implementation
at the local level. Besides, some studies draw on
foreign rural fire management systems and
experience, and some suggestions and measures, such