Self-Compassion in Mental Health Providers and Relevant

Interventions

Yutong Meng

Department of Psychology, Syracuse University, Syracuse, New York, U.S.A.

Keywords: Self-Compassion, Mental Health Professionals, Burnout Prevention, Emotional Resilience, Psychological

Interventions.

Abstract: Mental health providers are prone to high levels of burnout, emotional exhaustion and trauma from

exploration to distress and negative emotions. Self-compassion therefore becomes a key aspect in their self-

care. Self-compassion consists of the triad of self-kindness, common humanity, and mindfulness. It has been

validated as a mechanism for reducing stress, increasing resilience, and fostering improved emotional self-

regulation. Yet, while the self-compassion interventions show great promise, they have only been rarely used

in mental healthcare settings. This research article discusses the connection between self-compassion and

burnout, accentuating how self-compassion may be a shield for those who work in the mental health fields.

The primary section of the paper addresses the various strategies implemented to promote self-compassion

and to counteract burnout. It presents the effectiveness of Yoga-Based Stress Management (YBSM) and

cognitive behavioral stress management (CBSM), as well as the processes of promoting emotional resilience

and coping confidence. Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction (MBSR) and Compassion Based Mind Training

(CMT) are other interventional techniques that are included for encouraging emotional stability and self-

kindness. There are also, however, difficulties in using these methods, as well as an application of these

methods to other mental health-related professions. Although there is evidence of the effectiveness of self-

compassion in the short term, systematic studies on the durability of those interventions over time are lacking.

The future investigations ought to center on customizing self-compassion training for given job roles and

including it in workplace policies.

1 INTRODUCTION

Self-compassion, concluded by Clevenger,

encompasses being kind to oneself in suffering

situations, understanding that the same difficulties are

experienced by others, and keeping a wholesome

view of one’s feelings (Clevenger, 2019). The

strengthening effect of this assertive coping strategy

is supported by research that indicates a person who

has these justice-promoting values tends to show

better immunity to stressors, including symptoms of

depression and burnout (people become emotionally

exhausted, depersonalized, negative

emotionalization, and ineffective at what they do).

Burnout occurs mainly in occupations with high-

stress environments, such as mental healthcare, with

emotional demand being keen. Self-compassion,

therefore, seems to be a potential opportunity for

researchers who have passionate desire to discover

how it works on reducing burnout through decreasing

stress, promoting resilience, and building mental

wellness. This review paper focuses on recent

developments in the area of research on the self-

compassion-burnout link and methods of treatment.

Self-compassion is increasingly recognized as an

essential aspect of mental well-being. This is

especially critical in high-pressure jobs such as

healthcare. Specifically, rooted in Neff’s framework,

self-compassion including self-kindness, mindfulness

and common humanity are covered (Neff, 2003).

These aspects create emotional resilience and limit

self-criticism (Neff & Germer, 2013, Scheunemann et

al., 2019). Research shows that increasing levels of

self-compassion correlate with decreasing levels of

stress, anxiety, and burnout. This means that self-

compassion can act as a protective factor against

emotional strain usually related to work (Beaumont et

al., 2016).

Healthcare providers who possess a considerable

degree of self-compassion often report reduced

emotional exhaustion and higher resilience levels.

This points to the fact that self-acceptance positively

206

Meng, Y.

Self-Compassion in Mental Health Providers and Relevant Interventions.

DOI: 10.5220/0014111100004942

Paper published under CC license (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0)

In Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Applied Psychology and Marketing Management (APMM 2025), pages 206-211

ISBN: 978-989-758-791-7

influences stress management and professional

wellness (Clevenger, 2019). Various intervention

programs, including Mindfulness-Based Stress

Reduction (MBSR) and Compassionate Mind

Training (CMT), have evidenced the efficiency of

self-compassion development and emotional

regulation improvement (Beaumont & Martin, 2016).

While MBSR has significantly contributed to self-

compassion growth, its effect on burnout seems

inconsistent (Beaumont et al., 2016). Alternatively,

there are findings that claim that CMT for midwifery

is noted for having effectively cushioned self-

criticism. This suggests building emotional resilience

and possibilities for adopting its practice in varied

healthcare setups (Raab et al., 2015).

Despite these findings, it is crucial to conduct

further studies to determine the sustainability of self-

compassion practices. Also, researchers should

identify ways these interventions can be modified to

accommodate different healthcare careers. The

following sections will explore the link between self-

compassion and burnout in various professions. Also,

they will discuss how different program variants

should be structured. Finally, the paper will suggest

further recommendations.

Burnout is a psychological syndrome featuring

emotional exhaustion, depersonalization, and

underappreciated personal performance levels

(Maslach & Jackson, 1981). It is particularly

prevalent among mental health practitioners (MHPs)

due to the fact that they often work under highly

stressful conditions. MHPs work with emotional

distress on the job for extended periods. In addition,

high workloads that lead to strain and outbursts from

patient interactions make MHPs vulnerable to

burnout (Clevenger, 2019). Conversely, MHPs face

certain work-related stressors. These include a lack of

organizational support, administrative problems, and

limited coping opportunities. This situation

underscores the intricate interplay of these stressors,

intensifying burnout (Scheunemann et al., 2019).

While the consequences of burnout affect an

individual's practice, care, and healthcare system are

also compromised. Research shows a correlation

between burnout and decreased empathy, increased

medical errors, and lower intervention quality. In

summary, burnout hinders the realization of optimal

patient outcomes (Beaumont et al., 2016).

Furthermore, burnout levels contribute to workforce

shortages and job dissatisfaction. High turnover rates,

on the other hand, create another burden for mental

health services (Beaumont et al., 2016). Beyond this,

prolonged burnout has been noted to contribute to the

emergence of anxiety, depression, and physical

symptoms like sleep disturbances (Wiklund &

Wagner, 2013).

Meanwhile, several approaches have been made

to alleviate burnout. Self-compassion and structured

techniques for stress reduction are popular in these

strategies. MBSR and CMT have been proven

effective in boosting the level of self-compassion.

They also help in building emotional resilience and

decreasing occupational stress (Beaumont et al.,

2016). In addition, Yoga-Based Stress Management

(YBSM) and Cognitive Behavioral Stress

Management (CBSM) are favorably positioned to

reduce burnout and improve overall well-being

(Wiklund & Wagner,2013, Riley et al., 2017). Even

though these interventions have shown short-term

efficacy, further longitudinal studies should not

refrain from evaluating their viability and

effectiveness in a range of healthcare settings

(Clevenger, 2019).

The growing amount of research reveals that self-

compassion is a factored protection against burnout in

the healthcare profession. It not only increases their

workplace resilience but also helps manage stress in

the workplace. Studies carried out by Beaumont et al

(Scheunemann et al., 2019). show that self-

compassion is strongly linked to emotional coping

capacities. Those who have higher self-compassion

levels report lower levels of emotional exhaustion,

cope better, and demonstrate better psychological

well-being.

Intervention programs have been examined to

replenish self-compassion and alleviate burnout.

MBSR is an example of an effective intervention in

terms of self-kindness and less blame on the self for

experiencing emotional fatigue in professionals

engaged in mental healthcare (Scheunemann et al.,

2019). On par, CMT courses proved to be effective in

limiting self-criticism and enhancing emotion

regulation. This has been validated especially in

midwives and nurses (Scheunemann et al., 2019).

Nonetheless, these significant results do not

exhaust the topic, and there are still numerous areas

of concern. While the immediate benefits of self-

compassion training have been widely supported,

further studies are needed to establish the impact of

these practices in various healthcare settings over a

longer period, as Clevenger points out (Clevenger,

2019). In addition to that, more research should also

take into consideration modular interventions tailored

toward specific challenges by different healthcare

professions. This will widen the reach and ensure

lasting effects.

Although self-compassion is identified as a

protective factor in burnout, empirical research is still

Self-Compassion in Mental Health Providers and Relevant Interventions

207

lacking at some aspects. Most studies focus on

specific interventions in loneliness, often neglecting

the surrounding structures and their effects on long-

term consequences. Furthermore, the notion that

many of these studies, from various areas of

healthcare, approach healthcare in a generalized

manner fails to acknowledge the special emotional

burdens faced by mental health providers.

The upcoming sections will initially investigate

the patterns and methods of self-compassion in other

high-stress occupations to pinpoint shared features

and working options to be used. Next, attention will

be turned to the mental health providers, who will

have to deal with the specific barriers in the health

system and the strategies for overcoming them. This

review provides valuable recommendations for

increasing resilience and quality of life by integrating

these viewpoints.

2 THE ROLE OF SELF-

COMPASSION

2.1 The Psychological Influence of Self-

Compassion on Burnout and

Emotional Resilience

Burnout is a critical concern among mental health

providers (MHPs) is a critical issue, which manifests

in emotional exhaustion, a sense of depersonalization,

and diminished achievements on a personal level. The

presence of highly emotional demands and secondary

trauma creates a situation where MHPs are more

vulnerable to chronic stress, which, in turn, can lead

to burnout and reduced quality of care. Recent

literature brought attention to self-compassion as a

protective factor, through which an individual can

develop psychological resilience and emotional

regulation (Scheunemann et al., 2019).

Self-compassion involves three core elements:

emotional exhaustion, depersonalization, and low

personal fulfillment that enables a person to place

their personal suffering under a wider perspective,

fighting against emotional imbalance (Neff, 2003).

High self-compassion is associated with less

emotional exhaustion and lesser mental fatigue

among mental health providers, which reflects that

high self-compassion could help in lowering the

psychological cost of a high-stress work environment

(Clevenger, 2019). Research indicates a similar

conclusion that self-compassion is negatively related

to symptoms of anxiety, depression, and provider

compassion fatigue, all of which are implicated in

burnout (Beaumont et al., 2016).

Self-compassion survives not only loss of burnout

but also relates to a greater psychological resilience,

by means of which stressors can be processed without

excessive self-criticism. In this respect, the study of

self-compassion and psychotic-like experiences

(PLEs) provides evidence that individuals with high

self-compassion score had lower levels of distress

relating to PLEs, which indicates that self-

compassion provides opportunities for better

emotional processing and stress management (Neff,

2003). In the same way, psychosis recovery studies

discovered that self-acceptance and self-compassion

are the keys of resilience and post-traumatic growth

(PTG) (Raab et al., 2015). Hence, the evidence that

self-compassion does not only prevent burnout but

also recharges emotional energy and keeps mental

health on track is disclosed.

Nevertheless, the compassionate scientists are

aware that the methodology that emphasizes the

specific qualities of self-compassion is being

undersized despite important progress in the field.

While present-day research proposes self-kindness,

and the reduction of self-judgment as the main

factors, longitudinal studies are required to unveil

how self-compassion affects job satisfaction,

emotional regulation, and long-term career

fulfillment among mental health professionals

(Scheunemann et al., 2019). Regarding its potential

influence, the following section examines how self-

compassion operates in various mental health

professions and what exceptional problems they

experience in each case.

2.2 Self-Compassion Across Different

Mental Health Providers

While the addition of self-compassion is an effective

measure for controlling burnout, the influence of this

tool grows from profession to profession in the sphere

of mental health, depending on the type of emotional

demands and exposure to secondary trauma.

Providers who work with first responders, like those

in the fields of mental health and clinical psychology,

have a greater tendency to suffer from burnout

because of the nature of their job and the constant

presence of traumatic subject matter.

Mental health providers who deal with first

responders (like police officers, paramedics, and

firefighters) often are overwhelmed by high levels of

trauma exposure in the workplace. This type of

stressful job makes one more inclined to burn out. A

research project on mental health professionals who

APMM 2025 - International Conference on Applied Psychology and Marketing Management

208

work in the high-risk team showed that they require

self-compassion interventions tailored to their needs,

which may be trauma-focused self-compassion

training and resilience-building programs arranged in

a structured manner (Scheunemann et al., 2019).

Furthermore, the study emphasizes that the

development of emotional detachment as a

mechanism to cope with the stress leaves the person

at the risk of burnout. This further enhances the fact

that self-compassion is an important tool to help

professionals stay engaged and healthy at work

(Clevenger, 2019).

Clinical psychologists, psychiatrists, and licensed

therapists deal with chronic emotional demands and

empathy fatigue. They also have a heavy workload,

which makes them particularly vulnerable to burning

out. Studies indicate that self-compassion turns out to

be a significant factor in its preservation, as it helps

such professionals to look beneath the surface of

painful feelings: treatment failures, depression in

clients, and struggles with professional competence

by having developed emotional regulation

(Scheunemann et al., 2019). MHPs lacking in the

fundamental ingredient of self-compassion might be

tempted to adopt strategies of self-criticism and

emotional regulation, thereby aggravating burnout.

It has been found that telehealth systems have

made the burn-out dynamics different than those of

the mental health practitioners. On the one hand,

virtual sessions offer a tool for improving

accessibility of services. On the other hand, there are

worries of new stressors, such as emotional

disconnection and disintegration of separate private

and professional realms. Research has shown that

MHPs using teletherapy appreciate the fact that they

can virtually visit a patient at any time and that

structured interventions of self-compassion,

including mindfulness and self-kindness reflection,

come in handy to fight emotional isolation and fatigue

in remote therapy sessions (Clevenger, 2019).

3 INTERVENTIONS

STRATEGIES TO ENHANCE

SELF-COMPASSION AND

REDUCE BURNOUT IN

MENTAL HEALTH

PROVIDERS

Given the increasing evidence supporting self-

compassion as a protective factor against burnout,

various intervention strategies have been developed

to enhance emotional resilience and reduce

occupational stress among mental health providers.

Mental health professionals frequently encounter

high emotional demands, secondary trauma, and

compassion fatigue, all of which contribute to

burnout. While self-compassion has been identified

as a key mechanism for mitigating these challenges,

the effectiveness of specific interventions varies.

Several approaches, including YBSM, CBSM,

MBSR, and CMT, have been studied for their

potential in promoting emotional resilience and

reducing professional stress.

YBSM and CBSM have been extensively

examined as effective interventions for reducing

burnout. A comparative study found that both

methods led to improvements in physical health,

professional well-being, and reduced stress,

depression, and emotional exhaustion (Wiklund &

Wagner, 2013). However, YBSM was more effective

in reducing secondary trauma, improving emotional

resilience, and fostering self-compassion, whereas

CBSM was particularly beneficial in strengthening

coping confidence and problem-solving abilities

(Wiklund & Wagner, 2013). These findings suggest

that a combined approach integrating both cognitive-

behavioral techniques and mindfulness-based

practices may provide a more comprehensive strategy

for preventing burnout among mental health

providers.

MBSR is another widely studied intervention

aimed at enhancing self-compassion and stress

regulation. Research suggests that MBSR

significantly improves self-compassion, emotional

resilience, and psychological flexibility among

mental health professionals, helping them manage

occupational stress more effectively (Raab et al.,

2015). A pilot study found that MBSR participants

exhibited reductions in self-judgment, perceived

stress, and emotional exhaustion (Raab et al., 2015).

However, while MBSR contributes to emotional

well-being, its long-term effects on burnout reduction

remain inconclusive. Some studies have reported

limited improvements in overall job satisfaction,

highlighting the need for further research on its

sustained impact over time.

CMT has gained attention as a structured

intervention designed to foster self-compassion,

reduce self-criticism, and enhance emotional

regulation. A study examining CMT among mental

health trainees found that those who participated

reported lower levels of burnout, greater resilience,

and improved emotional coping skills (Beaumont et

al., 2016). Another study on CMT among

midwives—who experience occupational stress

Self-Compassion in Mental Health Providers and Relevant Interventions

209

levels similar with mental health professionals—

found that the intervention significantly reduced

secondary traumatic stress and increased self-

kindness (Beaumont & Martin, 2016). These findings

suggest that CMT could be effectively adapted for

mental health providers, offering structured methods

for developing self-compassion and mitigating

professional stress.

While these interventions show significant

potential, their integration into mental health training

programs remains limited. Many healthcare

organizations have yet to implement structured self-

compassion training as part of professional

development. Evidence suggests that making self-

compassion training a core component of mental

health education could significantly improve job

satisfaction and well-being (Beaumont et al., 2016).

By incorporating self-compassion interventions into

workplace initiatives, institutions can enhance

resilience, emotional health, and career sustainability

among mental health providers, ultimately benefiting

both professionals and the clients they serve.

4 CONCLUSIONS

This review discusses that self-compassion most

definitely plays a crucial part in reducing burnout

among mental health providers. Research reveals that

self-compassion is a psychological shield that enables

professionals to cope with emotional exhaustion,

secondary trauma, and workplace pressure more

effectively. It has been found that individuals with

higher self-compassion levels display lower burnout

and a greater recovery ability emotionally, which

implies that people could enjoy better professional

well-being by cultivating self-compassion.

Nevertheless, empirical evidence in favor of self-

compassion is well-spread, but mental health field

facilities rarely use formal procedures.

Burnout and lack of self-compassion have been

targeted using different intervention strategies.

YBSM and CBSM have both proved to be effective

in raising the overall well-being level, but the ex-

YBSM is especially advantageous in counteracting

secondary trauma, while CBSM serves to bolster the

coping implications. MBSR has also been searched

for a way of self-compassion improvement, its

effectiveness in emotional regulation as well as self-

kindness being proven; however, the long-term

impacts of MBSR on burnout prevention remain

ambiguous. The developing CMT model turned out

to be likely one of the promising treatments:

mitigated self-criticism and deepened balance in

emotions of staff members.

These interventions, however, only provide a

short-term benefit; longitudinal data is needed to

evaluate the sustainability of these changes in about a

year's time. Furthermore, nowadays, research

regarding self-compassion is widely focused on

instantaneous improvement; people do not measure

those raised levels of self-compassion after a while.

Furthermore, the existing studies are characterized by

a small number of subjects and methodological

disparity that makes it hard to spread the results

received to the diverse mental health professions.

More studies should look into variations in how self-

compassion interventions can be fitted to specific

professions, all to make sure that no burden is

imposed on any of the professionals who are

practicing in whichever clinical setting.

The integration of self-compassion training into

mental health care education and workplace policies

is no doubt the second crucial step. Institutions ought

to place self-compassion as a pillar of professional

development; students should be creating structured

training linked to employee-wellness programs.

Future studies should also test combined therapies

made mostly of cognitive-behavioral approaches,

mindfulness, and compassion techniques to make a

complete technique of burnout prevention. Besides

those shown in the above studies, studies are needed

to fill in the research holes so that mental health

organizations can offer psychological instruments to

handle these adversities. Such studies will increase

the mental health provider resilience and improve

patients care outcomes.

REFERENCES

Freeman Clevenger, S.: Is self-compassion important for

health care practitioners? OBM Integrative and

Complementary Medicine 4(1), 1-8 (2019).

Neff, K.: Self-compassion: An alternative

conceptualization of a healthy attitude toward oneself.

Self and identity 2(2), 85-101 (2003).

Neff, K. D., Germer, C. K.: A pilot study and randomized

controlled trial of the mindful self‐compassion

program. Journal of clinical psychology 69(1), 28-44

(2013).

Scheunemann, J., Schlier, B., Ascone, L., Lincoln, T. M.:

The link between self‐compassion and psychotic‐like

experiences: A matter of distress? Psychology and

Psychotherapy: Theory, Research and Practice 92(4),

523-538 (2019).

Beaumont, E., Durkin, M., Hollins Martin, C. J., Carson, J.:

Measuring relationships between self‐compassion,

compassion fatigue, burnout and well‐being in student

APMM 2025 - International Conference on Applied Psychology and Marketing Management

210

counsellors and student cognitive behavioural

psychotherapists: A quantitative survey. Counselling

and Psychotherapy Research 16(1), 15-23 (2016).

Beaumont, E., Martin, C. J. H.: Heightening levels of

compassion towards self and others through use of

compassionate mind training. British journal of

midwifery 24(11), 777-786 (2016).

Raab, K., Sogge, K., Parker, N., Flament, M. F.:

Mindfulness-based stress reduction and self-

compassion among mental healthcare professionals: a

pilot study. Mental Health, Religion & Culture 18(6),

503-512 (2015).

Maslach, C., Jackson, S. E.: The measurement of

experienced burnout. Journal of organizational

behavior 2(2), 99-113 (1981).

Wiklund Gustin, L., Wagner, L.: The butterfly effect of

caring–clinical nursing teachers’ understanding of self‐

compassion as a source to compassionate care.

Scandinavian Journal of Caring Sciences 27(1), 175-

183 (2013).

Riley, K. E., Park, C. L., Wilson, A., Sabo, A. N., Antoni,

M. H., Braun, T. D., Cope, S.: Improving physical and

mental health in frontline mental health care providers:

Yoga-based stress management versus cognitive

behavioral stress management. Journal of Workplace

Behavioral Health 32(1), 26-48 (2017).

Self-Compassion in Mental Health Providers and Relevant Interventions

211