Application of a Fuzzy Set and Fuzzy Logic to Economic Problems:
Study Literature Review of Journal
Suripah, Zetriuslita
Department of Mathematics, Universitas Islam Riau, Pekanbaru, Indonesia
Keywords:
Fuzzy Set, Fuzzy Logic, Economic Problems
Abstract:
This article aims to describe the set of application and fuzzy logic on the economy. The problems still faced
over the years is still the presence of obstacles how to create a formula approach to economic modeling. But
with the development of increasingly sophisticated technology, it must be followed by the progress of the
method approach refers to the development of mathematics and computer technology. Based on a review,
several studies in the field of economics has been developed to address the existing problems. As one
alternative approaches to modelling and in providing system solutions in the real world, especially for the
complexity of the system that are not easy to approach through mathematical modelling, fuzzy logic method
can be used as an alternative to solve the economic problems.
1 INTRODUCTION
The problems that occurred during this are the
constraints related to the discovery of a method for
the formulation and economic modelling approach.
(Flood and Marion, 1998) to suggest that there
are still challenges to find new methods for the
formulation and estimation of economic modeling in
order to obtain a high flexibility in the formulation
of functional; parametric assumptions as little as
possible; a good look for a data bit or a lot; as well as
the possibility of computing to support large number
of variables.
A long with the development of increasingly
sophisticated technology, it must be followed by
the progress of the method approach refers to
the development of mathematics and computer
technology. In the development of the past, for
modeling a system used a statistical method based
on the theory of probability that represent uncertainty.
However, this model has not succeeded in providing
an accurate prediction for a few series for the linear
structure and a few otherlimitations (Lin et al., 2002).
Therefore, around 1965, Professor LA Zadeh of the
University of California at Berkeley introduced a
vague set theory. Indirectly, this theory suggests
that there is a theory that can be used to represent
uncertainty. That is, as one alternative is fuzzy logic.
Fuzzy logic as a main component builder,
softcomputing has been shown to have excellent
ability to overcome the problems of uncertainty.
The set and fuzzy logic increasingly attracted many
researchers to be used as an alternative to data
analysis in research. Fuzzy logic implementation is
already very extensive, both in the fields of education,
agriculture, health, engineering, psychology, no less
important social and economic field.
In economics, has had its own association which
is named SIGEF (The International Association for
Management and Economy Fuzzyset), which was
formed on November 30 through December 2, 2006,
and hold the 13th congress in Morocco (Muslim,
2007). The congress is a forum for associations
of academics, professionals and practitioners in
the field of economics, management, finance, and
organizations to exchange ideas and experiences in
research, based on fuzzy logic, ant system, neural
systems, genetic algorithms, the theory of uncertainty
, complexity theory and softcomputing.
2 DISCUSSION
The discussion of several journal. articles application
of research results fuzzy set and fuzzy logic in the
economic that has been conducted by researchers
between 1987 to 2007. The results of the application
of the model used and to look into further fields are
described as follows.
Suripah, . and Zetriuslita, .
Application of a Fuzzy Set and Fuzzy Logic to Economic Problems: Study Literature Review of Journal.
DOI: 10.5220/0009059900790087
In Proceedings of the Second International Conference on Social, Economy, Education and Humanity (ICoSEEH 2019) - Sustainable Development in Developing Country for Facing Industrial
Revolution 4.0, pages 79-87
ISBN: 978-989-758-464-0
Copyright
c
2020 by SCITEPRESS Science and Technology Publications, Lda. All rights reserved
79
2.1 Fuzzy Logic
Theory of probability during the period of this
century, plays an important role to explain the notion
of uncertainty. In 1965, Prof. Lotfi A. Zadeh of
the University of California at Berkeley introduced
the concept of fuzzy sets indirectly this theory states
that in addition to the probability approach, the
uncertainty can also be done with a different approach
in this case using the concept of fuzzy set.
Fuzzy set theory is a mathematical framework
used to represent uncertainty, vagueness, inaccuracy,
lack information and partial truth (Studer and Masulli,
1997). Basically, vague set is an extension of classical
set (crisp), the classical set A an element will have two
possibilities, namely membership A member denoted
by uA (x). In the classical set of two memberships are
uA (x) = 1 if x is a member of A and uA (x) = 0 when
x is not a member of A.
In contrast to the classical set of fuzzy sets treating
elements in the degree of membership. For example
if the price of rice Rp 5,500 relatively expensive or
mediocrity? In the concept of fuzzy sets and in the
real world ”both statements are true” and perhaps as
an answer. The figure below shows the representation
of the price of rice in conventional sets and fuzzy sets.
Figure 1: Representation of the Association and Fuzzyfikasi
Value Crisp. Source: Adapted from Muslim (2017)
In classical logic truth values of right and wrong
is only worth it in the fuzzy logic truth values are
in the interval [0,1] which can be determined by
its membership function (Kaneko, 1996). Fuzzy
logic is an appropriate way to map an input space
into an output space based on the concept of fuzzy
sets (Velasco, 1987). As a general overview say
we have grouped the data into the data input and
output data of other groups is, between the input and
output are mapping process called black box, black
box where it describes a process that is not known.
To analyze the contents of the black box, there are
several approaches that can be used such as: linear
systems approach, econometrics, interpolation, expert
systems, fuzzy logic, etc. However, as disclosed Lotfi
Zadeh: ”In almost every case, fuzzy way faster and
cheaper”(Muslim, 2017).
2.2 Fuzzy Logic Applications on
Economic Affairs
Use of Fuzzy Logic for Research in Economics
Compared to conventional methods, for example
OLS, the application of fuzzy logic approach on
research in economics is still not a done deal.
However, this method can be used as an alternative
to modeling economic behavior. Economic modeling
is a form of abstraction of economic behavior in the
real world, in order to obtain a picture that is simpler
and easier to understand by humans. The modeling
used for ”real world” is too complex to be described
in detail. Although the details are not described by the
model, but a good model should be able to represent
anything that you want to know from the real world,
and also can predict the conditions that occur in the
real world. The following is some research in the field
of economics that uses fuzzy logic.
(Flood and Marion, 1998) in the “Output
convergence and International Trade: Time Series and
Fuzzy Clustering Evidence for New Zealand and Her
Trading Partners” introduces a new way to measure
the convergence in the form of time series data,
using the fuzzy c-means application in the clustering
algorithm. Fuzzy Grouping provide a clearer
picture of that difference in output will converge in
groups. In the same year, Giles on ”Econometric
Modeling based on Pattern Recognition via the Fuzzy
C-Means Clustering Encryption” using fuzzy logic
in particular grouping of fuzzy c-means in economic
modeling as a model of money demand with annual
data 1960-1983 American trade department, models
Kuznets’ U-Curve ”with a Gini coefficient data and
US real GDP from 1947 to 1991 and the results
show that the approach is better than the OLS and
non-parametric models.
Accurate prediction of stock market indices is
very important for certain reasons. Chief among the
needs of investors is the potential to hedge against
market risks, opportunities for market speculators and
to make profit by trading indices. Estimating the stock
market index accurately has profound and important
implications for researchers and practitioners.
The most commonly used technique for predicting
stock prices are the regression method and ARIMA
models (Box et al., 1970). Various models
and methods have been used extensively in the
past. However, they failed to provide accurate
prediction for several other limitations. Although
there are models of ARCH / GARCH Eichengreen,
(Eichengreen et al., 1995); (Bollerslev, 1986) models
to overcome non-linear variance, there are still some
series cannot be predicted satisfactorily. Recent
ICoSEEH 2019 - The Second International Conference on Social, Economy, Education, and Humanity
80
Table 1: Part 1. Selected literature on predictive economics problem mapping.
Study Modelling
Method
Variables Fields Goals attained
Achsani, NA.
2003
Auto
Regressive
Conditional
Heteroskedastic
(ARCH)
Y: national product at
1993 prices
R: interest rate
(long-term)
M: Money stock.
P: Consumer price index.
Mr: logarithmic real
balances.
Finance If the µ coefficient increases,
the interest rate elasticity
decreaces after the Asian
crisis
Agenor, PR, JS
Bhandari, and RP
Flood. 1992
Linear
regression
Payments Crises and
financial aspects
Finance There is a relationship
between payments crises and
financial aspects
Al-Shammari, M.
and Shaout, A.
1998
Fuzzy
personnel
performance
model
Teaching and instruction,
research and scholarly,
activities, service to the
department, output from
the fuzzy relations, merit
increase, promotions, and
tenure.
Organisation
/managerial
The modified model offers a
better evaluation performance
system since it allows
for dynamic changes in
the strength effect of the
input variables on output
performance.
Bollerslev, T.
1986.
ARCH,
Regression
models
Autoregressive
conditional
heteroskedasticity
General
economics
Empirical example relating to
the uncertainty of the inflation
rate is represented
Box, G. and
Jenkins, G. 1970.
ARIMA Busines
Buyukozkan. G.,
&Feyzioglu. O.
2004
Membership
function
New product development Manajemen
product
An increase in accuracy of
decision-making in NPD
underuncertainty
Chowdhry, B.,
Goyal, A. 2000
Survey Exploring the financial
crisis in Asia
Finance Represent the introduction
Dash, P. K., Liew,
A. C., Rahman,
S., & Dash, S.
1995
Fuzzy expert
system and a
hybrid neural
network-fuzzy
expert system
Load Forecasting General
field
Represent the introduction
Draeseke, R &
Giles, D.E. 2002
Multiple
indicators,
multiple causes
(MIMIC)
Tax rate and an index of
the degree of regulation.
Economic Relatively achieved
Eichengreen, B.,
AK Rose, and C.
Wyplosz. 1996
ARCH/GARCH The causes and
consequences.
Busines Answer the problem
statement
Application of a Fuzzy Set and Fuzzy Logic to Economic Problems: Study Literature Review of Journal
81
Table 2: Part 2. Selected literature on predictive economics problem mapping.
Study Modelling
Method
Variables Fields Goals attained
Engle, RF. 1982 ARCH,
Regression
models
United kingdom
inflation
Finance ARCH effects is found
to be significant and the
estimated variances increase
substantially during the
chaotic seventies.
Flood, R. and N.
Marion. 1998
Fuzzy c-Means
Clustering
Perspectives on
the recent currency
crisis
Finance Represent the introduction
Giles, DEA. 2005 Both bivariate
and multivariate
time-series
Time-series data
and fuzzy clustering
evidence for New
Zealand and trading
partners
Busines Time-series methods are able
to predict existing problems.
Giles, DEA and
R. Draeseke.
2017
Fuzzy c-mean
Encryption,
Econometric
modelling
recognition via
pattern
Economic Represent the introduction
Kahraman, C,
Tolga, E, and
Ulukan, Z. 2000
Fuzzy benefit
/cost ratio
analysis
Justification of
manufacturing
technologies
Manufacturing The method of operating cost
ratio (B/C) fuzzy logic is
used to justify the making
technology
Kaneko,
Takaomi. 199
Fuzzy Logic
and Fuzzy
Logic
Production
System
(FLOPS)
Financial diagnosis Finance FLOPS is recommended as a
function of financial diagnosis
Karsak, E. E., &
Tolga, E. 2001.
Fuzzy Multiple
Criteria
Decision
Making
(MCDM)
Evaluating
advanced
manufacturing
system investments.
Manufacturing The fuzzy decision-making
approach appears
as a consistent and
computational-efficient
alternative to existing
methods.
Lie, TT and
Sharaf, AM. 1995
Neuro-fuzzy
short-term load
forecasting
(STLF)
Self-correcting
online electric load
forecasting model
Economic Vector input affects the
estimated the short-term
forecast load.
Lin, CS et al.
2006
Neuro-fuzzy Currency crises Finance The neuro-fuzzy approach
produces better predictions
significantly.
Lin, CS; Khan,
HA & Huang,
CC. 2002
Neuro-fuzzy Stock indexes Busines Neuro fuzzy models predict
stock indexes better than its
rivals, neuro fuzzy consistent
over time.
ICoSEEH 2019 - The Second International Conference on Social, Economy, Education, and Humanity
82
Table 3: Part 3. Selected literature on predictive economics problem mapping.
Study Modelling
Method
Variables Fields Goals attained
Munakata,
Toshinori, and
Jani, Yashvant.
1994
Fuzzy system
include fuzzy
sets, logic,
algorithms, and
control
- An
overview
Fuzzy system are most
suitable for uncertain or
approximate reasoning,
particularly systems with
a algorithm model that is
difficult to be controlled.
Muslim, Aziz.
2017
Fuzzy logic Fuzzy logic in economics Economic In almost every case, fuzzy
way faster and cheaper
Obstfeld, M. 1994 Linear example Balance-of payments
crisis and Devaluation
Finance Thre are effects of the
influence of the balance of
payments crisis
Okada, H.,
Watanabe, N.,
Kawamura, A.,
and Azakawa, K.
1992
Artificial
Neural Network
(ANN)
combination of fuzzy
logic and ANN to
describe the input
An
overview
The system produces bond
ratings that are very suitable
for human experts, and are
able to generalize better than
a simple three-layer neural
network.
Ozkan, FG and A.
Sutherland. 1995
Fuzzy system
modelling,
type-I, FCM
Currency crises Finance The predictive power of
RBFSM is very encouraging.
Padmakumari,
K. Mohandas,
KP, and
Thiruvengadam,
S. 1999
ANN
Neuro-Fuzzy,
Radial Basis
Function
Network
(RBFN),
Land use based load
forecasting
Busines The RBFN is found to be
more suitable for long-term
prediction.
Studer, L. and
Masulli, F. 1997
Neuro-Fuzzy
system (NFS)
mackey Glass
time series
Layer of singleton inputs,
a hidden layer of Gaussian
membership functions
and one output unit
Organisation The use of a Neuro-Fuzzy
system for forecasting time is
promising
Velasco, A. 1987. Linear
regression
Bank crisis and payments
crisis
Finance There is a relationship
between bank crisis and
payments crisis
Zavadskas, E. K
and Turskis, Z.
2011
Fuzzy Multiple
Criteria
Decision
Making
(MCDM)
Multiple Criteria Decision
Making in Economics
Economic MCDM is effective for
supporting decisions in
several conditions.
Application of a Fuzzy Set and Fuzzy Logic to Economic Problems: Study Literature Review of Journal
83
research in neural network engineering has shown
that neural networks have the properties needed for
relevant applications, such as nonlinearity and fine
interpolation, the ability to learn nonlinear complex
mapping, and self-adaptation for different statistical
distributions.
However, neural networks cannot be used to
explain the causal relationship between input and
output variables. This is because the black box is
like the natural of most neural network algorithms.
Neural networks cannot be named with the underlying
knowledge. Networks must learn from the beginning,
while the learning process itself does not guarantee
success.
On the other hand, the expert system’s fuzzy
approach has been applied to the forecasting
of different problem (Bolloju, 1996), (Kaneko,
1996), (Shaout and Al-Shammari, 1998), where the
operator’s knoeledge to predict results. Although
forecasting is based on Fuzzy logic, the results
show that the process for constructing fuzzy- logic
system is subjective and depends on the heuristic
process. The choice of membership function and
basic rules must be developed heuristically for each
case. Rules in this way do not always produce
the best predictions, and the choice of membership
function still depends on trial and error. The
strengths and weaknesses of Neuro-fuzzy and fuzzy
logic, have combined the ability to learn from neural
networks and the functions of fuzzy expert systems.
Application can be found in (Dash et al., 1995),
(Studer and Masulli, 1997), and (Padmakumari et al.,
1999). For example the hybrid model is expected to
provide understanding to humans about the meaning
of ’Fuzzy’ through the various advantages can be
used as a concept of knowledge by studying neural
networks.
Some researchers such as (Jacobs and Levy,
1989), have claimed that the stock market is not a
system that can be explained by simple rules, nor
is it a random system that is impossible to predict.
In fact, they claim that the market is a complex
system, where the behaviour of the system can be
only be explained and predicted by a complex set of
relationships between variables.
Recognizing the complex characteristics of the
stock market to invites the researchers to further
investigate whether index variations can be improved
to predict nonlinear models using the neuro-fuzzy
approach. (Lin et al., 2002) in the ”Can the
neuro-fuzzy models predict stock indexes better than
its rivals?” Develop a model based on a trading
system by using a neuro fuzzy model to predict
stock indexes better. Thirty well-known stock indexes
were analyzed with the help of the developed model.
Empirically shows the corresponding non-linear
results in stock indexes using the KD technical index.
Analysis of trading points and analysis of trade costs
indicate endurance and opportunities for profit, it is
recommended to use nonlinear neuro fuzzy systems.
The analysis also shows that the recommended neuro
fuzzy is consistent over time.
In 2003, (
¨
Ozkan et al., 2004) in the ”Currency
Crises Analyzed By Type-I Fuzzy System
Modelling”, implementing softcomputing in the
analysis of a currency crisis, with test data time series
of data is the currency of Turkey. The method used
is the approach of macroeconomic time series data,
the Rule-based Fuzzy System Modelling (RBFSM)
become the focus of research and compared to
GARCH /ARMAX and ANFIS. The results show
that the GARCH approach / ARMAX and ANFIS no
better than predicted RBFSM.
Achsani, (2003) using a fuzzy cluster algorithm
to model the demand for Indonesia with the data in
1993: 4 to 2002: 3 even though the results are not
as good as the econometric model approach because
it does not consider the effect of autocorrelation and
seasonality of data, however, can explain in more
detail the grouping of economic periods. In the
same year, Achsani, (2003) back to do research using
Fuzzy-Clustering in data ASEAN + 3 as the ratio of
debt / GDP, exchange rate stability, inflation rate, and
the long term interest rate to determine the relative
position of Indonesia in the constellation of Asian
economies East.
In previous years some researchers report that
their concern for the problems of economic crisis.
They are concerned about theadverse consequences
of the policies needed to maintain economic variables
(Agenor et al., 1992; Flood and Marion, 1998;
Flood and Marion, 1998). While the traditional
approach emphasizes the role played by a decline in
foreign reserves in triggering the collapse of the fixed
exchange rate, some of the latest models suggest that
the decision to abandon the parity may occur based
on concerns about the evolution of the economic
authorities. On the other hand, variables indicate that
groups of other variables can be useful for predicting
the currency crisis (Ozkan and Sutherland, 1995) and
(Velasco, 1987). In addition, the latest model also
suggested that the crisis can develop in the absence
of fundamental changes in the real economy. This
model emphasizes that the nature of the contingency
of economic policy may pose some equlibria and
produce that meets its own crisis (Obstfeld, 1983).
Some recent research has focused on the effects of the
balance of payments crisis (Eichengreen et al., 1995).
ICoSEEH 2019 - The Second International Conference on Social, Economy, Education, and Humanity
84
All these models recommend possible variables as the
main indicators of crisis. However, some new works
are opposing, for example (Chowdhry and Goyal,
2000), the results of the sample data forecasting
beyond a theoretical model for the case of the Asian
financial crisis is largely disappointing.
(Lin et al., 2002) in ”A New Approach to
Modeling Early Warning Systems for Currency
Crises: can a machine-learning fuzzy expert system
predict the currency crises Effectively?”. Back
conduct research using Neuro-Fuzzy approach to
predict the crisis in Indonesia, Philifina, Thailand,
and Malaysia. This model integrates the learning
ability with fuzzy logic inference. The empirical
it shows that the neuro-fuzzy approach produces
significantly better predictions. Compared to
traditional approaches such as logit techniques.
In 2007, (Muslim, 2007) in the ”Implementation
Algorithms and Neuro Fuzzy Fuzzy Cluster Case
Studies Indonesia’s exports to Japan” provide
an alternative modeling especially data modeling
Indonesian exports to Japan by applying algorithms
and Neuro Fuzzy Fuzzy Cluster. MAPE size and
Theils Inequality shows that both methods have
a good performance to estimate export. When
compared to conventional methods OLS-AR fuzzy
method provides better results. Prediction of the
input-output relationship on Fuzzy Cluster Algorithm
can predict their objective structural break in 1993:
Q2 and 1997: Q4 and evidenced by subjective
methods chow-test. Modeling indicates that there is
a conditional relationship in the model of Indonesian
exports to Japan, in the context of these relationships
are fuzzy low, medium, high, while in the context of
time is pre Japanese Slump, after the Japanese Slump,
post-crisis Indonesia.
2.3 Fuzzy Logic Applications in the
Field of Business
Use information technology becomes an important
part in business management in the 21st century
now. Today information technology were mostly
used to process data and efficient support effective
communication in business management. Predictions
of the future of information technology will be used
as a decision-making tool automatically, have the
intelligence capability to analyze and be able to do
the learning to make optimal decisions. For that
we need a system that is able to behave like a
human being in terms of thinking and make decisions
rationally. Fuzzy logic is a concept that can be used
to meet the demands of the system. In the business
world has made several application programs based
on fuzzy logic are: (Munakata and Jani, 1994), early
application in the trading world using fuzzy approach.
The system handles 65 industrial stocks in the Dow
and the Nikkei 800 rule prescribed by the experts and
if necessary repaired by senior business analyst. This
system has been tested for 2 years and performance
by using Nikkei Average showed an increase of over
20%. When tested this system recommends ”sell”
18 days before the ”Black Monday” in 1987. The
system is operated commercially in 1988. Most
financial analysts, agree to say that the ”rule” for the
trade was ”fuzzy”. Convertible Bond Rating, Nikko
Securities, has been using ANN to raise the rating
convertible bond since twenty seven years ago (Okada
et al., 1992). This system of learning from expert
instruction reaction rating, which change according to
economic circumstances. The system will analyze the
results, and using the results to advise. The system
consists of a combination of fuzzy logic and ANN to
describe the input. Ratio of the correct answer is 96%.
In (2000) (Kahraman et al., 2000) in the
”Justification of manufacturing technologies using
fuzzy benefit or cost ratio analysis”. The application
of fuzzy logic is used for the application of cash
discount techniques to justify the manufacturing
technologies studied many documents. The net value
of the country’s stock and stochastic value now are
two examples of this application. This application
is based on data that is outside the range. If we
have the faint of data such as interest rates and cash
applying the techniques of cash discounts, fuzzy set
theory can be used to resolve this uncertainty. Fuzzy
set theory has the ability to represent data and the
vague and allows the operator to apply mathematical
programming fuzzy domain. This theory is primarily
concerned with measuring uncertainty in the mind
and human perception. On paper, with the assumption
that we have data that is not clear, the method of
operating cost ratio (B/C) fuzzy logic is used to justify
the making technology. After calculating the B/C
ratio based on annual values, it turns out that the two
manufacturing systems have different cycles.
(Draeseke and Giles, 2002) in the ”A fuzzy logic
approach to modeling the New Zealand underground
economy”. Implementing fuzzy logic to analyze the
importance of the availability of data on the size
of the economy ”under” (EU) for macroeconomic
policy. They use fuzzy set theory and fuzzy logic
to draw up an annual time series for New Zealand
unobserved EU during the twenty six year. Two
input variables used in effective tax rate and the
index of the level of regulation (REG). The result
of time series UE compared to the previously built.
Second, the authors use the model of ”multiple
Application of a Fuzzy Set and Fuzzy Logic to Economic Problems: Study Literature Review of Journal
85
indicators, multiple cause” (MIMIC) structural. Both
approaches produce each UE Photo New Zealand
sensible but somewhat different during this period.
The fuzzy logic approach to this problem involves
several subjective considerations, but the results are
quite satisfactory.
Research activities in the economic field during
the last five years it has increased significantly.
(Zavadskas and Turskis, 2011; B
¨
uy
¨
uk
¨
ozkan
and Feyzıoglu, 2004; Karsak and Tolga, 2001).
Conducting research in the ”Multiple Criteria
Decision Making (MCDM) Methods In Economics:
An Overview”. Suggests that the main research
field is the study of operations and sustainable
development. That philosophy of decision-making
in the economic field is to assess and choose the
most recommended solution, apply it and to get the
greatest benefits. Alternatives methods applied in
problematic conditions both in the decision-making
process of individuals or organizations. Several of
effective decision making methods support decisions
in conditions where several criteria have emerged
in the last decade. The Paper’s presents methods
of decision-making in the field of economics and a
summary of results and important applications over
the last five years. The paper considers the decision
making considering the development of some of
the latest methods of decision-making criteria (for
the classic method is discussed in many previous
publications). Researchers here using a different
approach, pioneering studies and papers presented
briefly.
The comparative analysis results of the reviewed
article are presented in the following table:
3 CONCLUSIONS
The rapid development of technology and computers
to follow the development of economic modeling
representative. As one alternative approaches to
modeling and in providing system solutions in the real
world, especially for the complexity of the system
that are not easy to approach through mathematical
modeling, can be used as an alternative method of
fuzzy logic to solve problems. As for some reason
it is advisable to use fuzzy logic is:
Conceptually easy to use because it is based on a
simple mathematical concept.
Their tolerance to uncertainty data;
Program to model the system that is not linear and
complex;
Working system is based on everyday human
communication.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The researchers express special thanks to Universitas
Islam Riau which has facilitated this study.
REFERENCES
Agenor, P.-R., Bhandari, J. S., and Flood, R. P.
(1992). Speculative attacks and models of balance of
payments crises. Staff Papers, 39(2):357–394.
Bollerslev, T. (1986). Generalized autoregressive
conditional heteroskedasticity. Journal of
econometrics, 31(3):307–327.
Bolloju, N. (1996). Formulation of qualitative models
using fuzzy logic. Decision support systems,
17(4):275–298.
Box, G. E., Jenkins, G. M., and Reinsel, G. (1970). Time
series analysis: forecasting and control holden-day
san francisco. BoxTime Series Analysis: Forecasting
and Control Holden Day1970.
B
¨
uy
¨
uk
¨
ozkan, G. and Feyzıoglu, O. (2004). A
fuzzy-logic-based decision-making approach for new
product development. International journal of
production economics, 90(1):27–45.
Chowdhry, B. and Goyal, A. (2000). Understanding the
financial crisis in asia. Pacific-Basin Finance Journal,
8(2):135–152.
Dash, P., Liew, A., Rahman, S., and Dash, S. (1995). Fuzzy
and neuro-fuzzy computing models for electric load
forecasting. Engineering Applications of Artificial
Intelligence, 8(4):423–433.
Draeseke, R. and Giles, D. E. (2002). A fuzzy logic
approach to modelling the new zealand underground
economy. Mathematics and computers in simulation,
59(1-3):115–123.
Eichengreen, B., Rose, A. K., and Wyplosz, C. (1995).
Exchange market mayhem: the antecedents and
aftermath of speculative attacks. Economic policy,
10(21):249–312.
Flood, R. and Marion, N. (1998). 0perspectives on the
recent currency crisis literature. 1 national bureau of
economic research workm ing paper no. 6380.
Jacobs, B. I. and Levy, K. N. (1989). The complexity of
the stock market. Journal of Portfolio Management,
16(1):19.
Kahraman, C., Tolga, E., and Ulukan, Z. (2000).
Justification of manufacturing technologies using
fuzzy benefit/cost ratio analysis. International
Journal of Production Economics, 66(1):45–52.
Kaneko, T. (1996). Building a financial diagnosis system
based on fuzzy logic production system. Computers
& industrial engineering, 31(3-4):743–746.
ICoSEEH 2019 - The Second International Conference on Social, Economy, Education, and Humanity
86
Karsak, E. E. and Tolga, E. (2001). Fuzzy multi-criteria
decision-making procedure for evaluating advanced
manufacturing system investments. International
journal of production economics, 69(1):49–64.
Lin, C.-S., Khan, H. A., Huang, C.-C., et al. (2002). Can the
neuro fuzzy model predict stock indexes better than
its rivals? Discussion Papers of University of Tokyo
CIRJE-F-165.
Munakata, T. and Jani, Y. (1994). Fuzzy systems: an
overview. Communications of the ACM, 37(3):69–77.
Muslim, A. (2007). 2007. Cluster Algorithm
Implementation of Fuzzy and Neuro Fuzzy Model
Case Studies Indonesia’s exports to Japan.
Muslim, A. (2017). 2017. The use of fuzzy logic in
economics. (2017). Retrieved on December, 28.
Obstfeld, M. (1983). Balance-of-payments crises and
devaluation.
Okada, H., Watanabe, N., Kawamura, A., Asakawa, K.,
Taira, T., Ishida, K., Kaji, T., and Narita, M. (1992).
Initializing multilayer neural networks with fuzzy
logic. In [Proceedings 1992] IJCNN International
Joint Conference on Neural Networks, volume 1,
pages 239–244. IEEE.
Ozkan, F. G. and Sutherland, A. (1995). Policy measures
to avoid a currency crisis. The Economic Journal,
105(429):510–519.
¨
Ozkan, I., T
¨
urksen, I., and Aktan, O. (2004). Currency
crises analyzed by type-i fuzzy system modelling.
Fuzzy Economic Review, 9(1):35.
Padmakumari, K., Mohandas, K., and Thiruvengadam, S.
(1999). Long term distribution demand forecasting
using neuro fuzzy computations. International
Journal of Electrical Power & Energy Systems,
21(5):315–322.
Shaout, A. and Al-Shammari, M. (1998). Fuzzy logic
modeling for performance appraisal systems: a
framework for empirical evaluation. Expert systems
with Applications, 14(3):323–328.
Studer, L. and Masulli, F. (1997). Building a
neuro-fuzzy system to efficiently forecast chaotic
time series. Nuclear Instruments and Methods
in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators,
Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment,
389(1-2):264–267.
Velasco, A. (1987). Financial crises and balance of
payments crises: a simple model of the southern
cone experience. Journal of development Economics,
27(1-2):263–283.
Zavadskas, E. K. and Turskis, Z. (2011). Multiple criteria
decision making (mcdm) methods in economics: an
overview. Technological and economic development
of economy, 17(2):397–427.
Application of a Fuzzy Set and Fuzzy Logic to Economic Problems: Study Literature Review of Journal
87