
 
Bathari  Guru  or  Permaisuri  Retno  Dewi  Utami 
(Panuju,  2004)  The  women  who  also  had  a  very 
close relation to Arjuna in AMM were Srikandi and 
Banowati.  Those  two  characters  were  presented  as 
Arjuna’s  wives.  In  the  wayang  world,  these  two 
women were  indeed  Arjuna’s wives. Dewi Srikandi 
was  described  as  a  beautiful  woman,  good  at 
military  knowledge.    Moreover,  some  puppeteers 
mention, Srikandi wore a complete military costume 
when she was delivered to this world. She was good 
at archery for Arjuna taught her (Tim Penulis Sena 
Wangi, 1999).  
In  AMM,  Srikandi’s  skill  at  archery  was  not 
visible. The dominant thing about her was that her 
jealousy. She was jealous for Arjuna loved Banowati 
so much (Panuju, 2004, p. 127). In the wayang story, 
Dewi Banowati was a beautiful and spoiled princess 
of Prabu Salya from Mandukara Kingdom. She was 
the wife of Duryodana,  although she  was  badly  in 
love with  Arjuna. All puppeteers agreed that Dewi 
Banowati was a kind of disloyal wife. After getting 
married  to  Duryodana,  she  kept  on  loving  Arjuna 
(Tim  Penulis  Sena  Wangi,  1999).  In  AMM,  it  was 
told  that  Banowati  married  Arjuna  although  her 
husband  was  still  alive,  and  it  was  shown  as  if 
Arjuna was the one who admired her, not Banowati. 
Whereas, Banowati herself still felt affection to her 
husband,  that  was  why  she  was  determined  to  do 
emasculation to Arjuna (Panuju, 2004). 
In AMM, the story fact element, particularly the 
setting  and  characters,  were  not  slightly  different. 
Even  so,  the  sequences  and  characters’  behaviour 
got  reversed  and  diverged.  For  instance,  Cakil  or 
Buta  Cakil  was  a  giant  character  in  the  wayang 
world, but he had small body. He appeared in many 
stories  with  various  names,  such  as  Ditya  Kala 
Gendir  Penjalin,  Ditya  Kala  Carang  Aking,  Kala 
Klantang  Mimis.  He  was  the  one  and  only  giant 
weapon called keris, not one but two, but sometimes 
three. But he always died being stabbed by his own 
keris.  Because  of  this,  in  Javanese  society  he  was 
frequently used as a model of bad behaviour. When 
somebody got trouble because of his/her behaviour, 
he/she was considered resembling  Buta Cakil (Tim 
Penulis  Sena  Wangi,  1999)  Nonetheless,  in  AMM  
Cakil  was  a  protagonist  character  for  his  help  to 
Tegar  when  he  was  robbed  by  mask  burglars 
(Panuju, 2004). 
In the wayang and Mahabharata epic, Dursasana 
was Duryodana’s  young brother.  In  wayang shows, 
especially living actors, he was easily recognized for 
his big tall body and hands and legs movement. He 
was  the  symbol  of  less  educated,  unethical,  and 
uncivilized person (Tim Penulis Sena Wangi, 1999). 
In the contrary,  in  AMM,  he was  a  kindly-hearted, 
polite and tried to help others (Panuju, 2004). 
The  characters  who  also  showed  different 
characteristics  are  punakawan  or  servants,  namely 
Semar and his sons. Semar or Ki Lurah Semar, was 
the  main  servant  in  the  wayang  world.  Like  other 
servants,  he  was  the  original  wayang  figure  from 
Indonesia. In Mahabharata epic, nothing  mentioned 
about  these  unique  characters.  Semar  and  his  sons 
were  narrated  to  always  follow  Pandawa  clan.  It 
pointed  out  that  they  went  along  with  the  right 
people. In the opposite, in AMM, Pandawa clan was 
the center of corruption, collusion and nepotism, and 
Semar  was  supposed  to  resuscitate  them. 
Unfortunately,  Semar,  who  was  mentioned  as 
Goddess offspring, even conspired with the clan and 
tried  to  betray  Duryodana,  Sengkuni,  dan  Tegar 
(Panuju, 2014). 
In  the  wayang  story,  Arjuna  finally  married  to 
Dewi Banowati. Yet he did it after Banowati became 
a  widow,  as  her  husband  died  in  Kurusetra  battle 
field.  In  AMM  Arjuna  arrogated  Banowati  from 
Duryodana after Yudistira shoving aside Duryodana 
from Astina Kingdom. Here Arjuna seemed to love 
Banowati so much, while Banowati still admired her 
husband so  that  she was determined  to  emasculate 
Arjuna.    
Manliness  and  Pasopati  were  Arjuna’s  pride. 
From that moment, Arjuna did not live his life any 
longer  so  he went  for  adventure to  look for  death. 
Loosing those two weapons led him to  give up his 
life. He thought everything came to the end (Panuju, 
2004). 
4.3  The Mapag Perang Barata (MPB) 
Sundanese Novel by Ahmad Bakri 
The MPB were generally same as the wayang story, 
particularly Mahabharata and Bharatayuda. Even so, 
there were some differences emerged. There was no 
punakawan  or  servant  appeared,  such  as  Lurah 
Semar and his sons, whereas they were the special 
characteristics  of  wayang  characters,  especially  in 
Indonesia,  which  has  never  found  in  Mahabharata 
epic.    
Relating  to  Mahabharata  epic,  there  were  a 
number  of  similar  facts  discovered.  However,  in 
terms of plot, it seemed that the novel removed the 
event  of dice match between Pandawa (Yudhistira) 
and  Kurawa  (Sakuni).  In  fact,  this  was  slightly 
crucial event that led to the Barata or Bharatayuda 
war.  In  MPB,  the  event  considered  crucial  was 
Pandawa  adventure  after  the  incident  in 
Waranawata,  or  in  the  wayang  story,  it  was  well-
The Arjuna Myth within Two Indonesian Novels and One Sundanese Novel: A Comparative Literature Analysis
805