Design and Fabrication of Optical Devices based on New
Polyfunctional Photo-thermo-refractive Glasses
Nikolay Nikonorov, Vladimir Aseev, Victor Dubrovin, Alexander Ignatiev, Sergey Ivanov,
Yevgeny Sgibnev and Alexander Sidorov
Department of Optoinformatic Technologies and Materials, ITMO University, St.Petersburg, Russia
Keywords: Photo-thermo-refractive Glass, Ion-exchangeable Glass, Photoetchable Glass, Bragg Grating, Waveguide,
Phosphors, Down-converter, Thermo-sensor, Biosensor.
Abstract: Novel optical elements and devices (holographic volume Bragg gratings, gradient optical elements, optical
and plasmonic waveguides, hollow structures, thermo-and biosensors, phosphors for LEDs, down-converters
for solar cells) have been designed and fabricated based on new polyfunctional photo-thermo-refractive
glasses. Some technologies (photo-thermo-induced crystallization, holograms recording, laser treatment, ion
exchange, chemical etching) have been used. Shown that photo-thermo-refractive glasses can be used as a
basic optical material for many photonics applications with the characteristics comparable with other
commercially available materials.
1 INTRODUCTION
The current stage of development of optical, photonic
and plasmonic devices calls for new and most likely
miniature optical elements that cannot be fully
implemented on the basis of traditional materials and
technologies. Therefore, the great attention is being
paid worldwide to the development of novel optical
materials.
The novel fluorine, chlorine and bromine photo-
thermo-refractive (PTR) glasses developed in ITMO
University (St. Petersburg, Russia) are very
promising optical materials for optical, photonic and
plasmonic applications (Nikonorov et al., 2010).
PTR glass is a multicomponent photosensitive
sodium-zinc-aluminosilicate glass doped with
halogens (fluorine, chlorine or bromine) and also
antimony, cerium, and silver (Dubrovin et al., 2014).
The PTR glass changes its refractive index after an
exposure to the near UV radiation followed by
thermal treatment at temperatures close to the glass
transition one (Tg). For example, in case of fluorine
PTR glass, that results in the precipitation of nano-
crystalline phases of NaF in glass host and negative
increment of RI (n = - 1000 ppm). In other words, it
results in decrease of RI in UV irradiated area in
comparison with unirradiated area of glass. In case of
chlorine and bromine PTR glasses that results in
growth of AgCL and AgBr nanocrystals and positive
increment of RI (n = + 1500 ppm).
The sizes of NaF, AgCL and AgBr nanocrystals
are relatively small (10-20 nm), that is why PTR
glasses exhibit rather a low level of scattering. The
fluorine PTR glass is successfully used for the
fabrication of holographic optical elements (HOEs)
that dramatically enhance properties of numerous
laser systems and spectrometers. It shows high
photosensitivity, high thermal stability of the
recorded phase holograms, and high tolerance to
optical and ionizing irradiation. Basic optical and
spectral properties of fluorine PTR glass are
described in (Glebova et al., 2008; Efimov et al.,
2011). The HOEs recorded in the fluorine PTR glass
reveal high chemical stability, thermal, mechanical
and optical strength, and from this point of view
practically reveal no difference with the commercial
optical glass BK7 (Schott). The optical and spectral
parameters of the HOEs and GRIN-elements do not
change after its multiple heating to the high
temperature (500ºC). The important advantages of the
fluorine PTR glass as the optical medium are
following: (i) high optical uniformity (the refraction
index fluctuations across the glass volume have the
scale of some 10
-5
), (ii) reproducibility of its
parameters during the starting glass synthesis and
during the photo-thermo-induced crystallization, (iii)
similarity to optical glass BK7, the PTR glass can be
20
Nikonorov, N., Aseev, V., Dubrovin, V., Ignatiev, A., Ivanov, S., Sgibnev, Y. and Sidorov, A.
Design and Fabrication of Optical Devices based on New Polyfunctional Photo-thermo-refractive Glasses.
DOI: 10.5220/0005676700180025
In Proceedings of the 4th International Conference on Photonics, Optics and Laser Technology (PHOTOPTICS 2016), pages 20-27
ISBN: 978-989-758-174-8
Copyright
c
2016 by SCITEPRESS Science and Technology Publications, Lda. All rights reserved
subjected to various methods of mechanical
processing like grinding and polishing as well as
various formation technologies like molding,
aspheric surface production, and drawing fiber, (iv)
one can fabricate the PTR glass both in laboratory
(some hundreds grams) and in industrial (some
hundreds kilograms) conditions with the use of
simple and non-toxic technology. The chemical
reagents, which are necessary for glass fabrication,
are commercially available and not too expensive.
One has also to note some features of the fluorine
PTR glass, which are unusual for recording media.
For example, such media can be subjected to the ion-
exchange technology, that providing the possibility to
fabricate the ion-exchanged optical or plasmonic
waveguides and the surface strengthening to improve
the mechanical strength, chemical stability, thermal
and optical strength of the PTR glass. Moreover, the
photoetchable technology can be used in PTR glass to
provide the possibility to fabricate “lab-on-a-chip”
systems and optical microfluidic devices. PTR glass
doped with rare earth ions reveals good laser
characteristics (Aseev and Nikonorov, 2008; Glebova
et al., 2011).Recording the Bragg gratings in laser
PTR glass opens up a possibility to develop lasers
with distributed feedback. In (Hofmann et al., 2013),
possibilities to draw optical fibers from PTR glass
and record the Bragg gratings in the fiber are shown.
Some characteristics of fluorine PTR-glass and
VBGs are demonstrated in Table 1.
Table 1: Characteristics of fluorine PTR-glass.
Transparency range, nm 350-3000
Photosensitivity spectral range, nm 280-350
Photosensitivity, mJ/cm2 50
RI change, Δn
1×10
-3
RI modulation amplitude, δn 5×10
-4
Induced optical loss, cm-1
- visible range
- near IR range
0.1
0.001
Space frequency, mm-1 up to 5000
Diffraction efficiency, % 95
Hologram thickness, mm 0.1-10
Angular selectivity, ang. min <1
Bandwidth FWHM, nm 0.1
Size, mm up to 25×25
VBGs are completely stable at temperature,
o
C 200
2 DESIGN AND FABRICATION
OF OPTICAL DEVICES
2.1 Holographic Optical Elements
2.1.1 Volume Bragg Gratings for Laser
Diodes
Wide spread of laser diodes connected with its high
energy conversion efficiency, small size, simplicity
of use and low cost. However, as it well known laser
diodes has wide emission spectra and absence of
spectral stability caused by temperature shifts during
operation. This problem can be solved by mean of
VBG, due to high spectral selectivity of recorded
holograms implementation of such grating inside
external cavity of laser diode can significantly narrow
the output spectra. On the picture below is shown
emission of laser diode with and without grating. As
one can see grating narrows emission spectra from
6nm down to 6pm. Furthermore, due to high
transparency of HOE on PTR glass there’s almost no
losses in resulting output power. Moreover, gratings
can provide tunability for such lasers. By simple
rotation of the element one can change output
wavelength in a wide range. As experiments shows
such laser can be tuned in the whole range of diode
gain spectral range, which is about 10 nm.
Figure 1: Emission spectra of laser diode source with (1)
and without (2) grating.
2.1.2 Imaging Holograms for Collimator
Sight
High transparency of novel material in visible range
(above 90% without AR) opens a new field of
applications with strict requirements to transmission
in observation channel such as collimator sight.
Application of PTR glass can solve problem of mark
Design and Fabrication of Optical Devices based on New Polyfunctional Photo-thermo-refractive Glasses
21
image stabilization, which is necessary due to the
instability of laser diode source used in such scopes.
To date this problem is solved by addition in optical
scheme achromatizing diffraction elements such as
additional thin gratings, complex two-cavity mirrors
or compound objectives. Wavelength shift, caused by
laser diode temperature changes, can be nullified by
spectral selectivity of thick hologram recorded on
PTR glass. While the central wavelength of laser
diode shifts, recorded hologram continues to
reconstruct image of mark on proper angle – thus
maintaining the position of mark in target plane.
Moreover, redistribution of energy in diode output
spectra leads to insignificant lowering of intensity of
the mark that can be easily leveled by diode power
output adjustment. Since the diffraction efficiency of
holograms on PTR glass can achieve values of 99%,
intensity required for mark observation is pretty low.
Worth noting that up to date materials used for mark
recording are vulnerable to external impact such as
moisture and mechanical damage, that leads to need
in additional cover for holograms. With application
of PTR glass, since it is high resistant to external
impacts, there is no need in additional protection of
observation channel. In Figure 2 observable image of
holographic mark is demonstrated.
Figure 2: Photo of a reconstructed image of a volume
holographic mark.
2.2 Optical Amplifiers
We have demonstrated an optical amplification in the
laser PTR glass doped with rare earth ions (Er
3+
and
Yb
3+
). The concentration of ytterbium ions was
equaled to 17.8×10
20
cm
-3
. The concentration of
erbium ions was varied from 0 to 2.26×10
20
cm
3
. The
introducing rare earth ions into the virgin PTR glasses
did not change its photosensitive properties.
The experimental spectral dependences of the
gain/loss coefficient for various pump power are
shown in Fig. 3.
Figure 3: Gain/loss spectrum of PTR glass ceramics with
various pump power
.
N
Er
=0.26×10
20
cm
3
, N
Yb
=17.6×10
20
cm
3
.
As the pumping power increases, the absorption
spectrum transforms into a gain spectrum. The gain
coefficient at wavelength of 1.55 μm was close to
commercial Yb-Er silicate glass and achieved
g=0.016 cm
-1
. The gain is obtained on the samples
with a minimum erbium-ion concentration
N
Er
=0.26×10
20
cm
3
and N
Er
=0.56×10
20
cm
3
.
Increasing the erbium-ion concentration reduces the
gain.
The combination of laser and holographic
photorefractive properties into the laser PTR glass
substrate allowed us to realize a monolithic
integration of optical amplifier with Bragg grating
playing a role of spectral flattening filter.
2.3 Optical Waveguides
The virgin PTR glass contains 15-20 mol % of Na
2
O.
That fact allowed us to consider the PTR glass as ion-
exchangeable medium and use an ion-exchange
technology for optical and plasmonic waveguides
fabrication. The optical waveguides have been
prepared with the use of exchange of Na
+
(glass)
Ag
+
,
K
+
, Rb
+
, Cs
+
(salt)
from melt of corresponding nitrate.
In the case of Na
+
(glass)
Ag
+
(salt)
optical waveguides
reveal no birefringence and RI increment caused by
differences in the polarizabilities of cations
exchanged achieves Δn=0.014. In case of replacing
the sodium ions in glass by other alkali cations
(potassium, rubidium, and cesium), the refractive
index profile in waveguides formed by not only
differences of ions’ in the polarizabilities of ions
under exchange but also due to the photoelastic effect
arising at the expense of the compressive mechanical
PHOTOPTICS 2016 - 4th International Conference on Photonics, Optics and Laser Technology
22
stresses under the exchange of ions with various ionic
radii. Such mechanical stresses can improve
physicochemical properties of glass surface
(mechanical strength, microhardness, thermal
stability, and optical durability). For example, our
measurements showed an increase in Vickers
microhardness of PTR glass from 554 MPa before the
potassium IE to 655 MPa after the IE (temperature
and duration being 350
о
С and 6h). The RI increment
reaches 0.01 for K
+
-waveguides, 0.025 for Rb
+
-
waveguides and 0.05 for Cs
+
-waveguides. The optical
losses of the waveguides do not exceed 0.5 dB/cm.
Thus, we made a conclusion that the ion-
exchangeable properties of the PTR glass are
comparable with ones of commercial optical glass of
BK7 used for optical waveguides fabrication. In case
of Ag
+
-waveguides the silver ions can be transformed
into silver metallic nanoparticles by thermal
treatment in reducing atmosphere. This technology
allowed us to fabricate plasmonic waveguides with a
strong surface plasmon resonance used for chemical
and biological sensors.
2.4 Photoetchable Media for
Microfluidic, MEMS and MOEMS
Devices
A technology of chemical etching of the fluorine PTR
glass has been developed for the first time. The rate
of etching of the crystalline phase is much higher than
one for the glass host by factors of 6-10.
Figure 4: Dependences of etching rates for PTR glass (1)
and fluorine glass ceramics (2) on the HF concentration in
aqueous solution.
In Fig. 4 are shown dependences of etching rate
on the HF concentration in aqueous solution for glass
and fluorine glass ceramics. It’s obvious that glass
ceramics reveal the higher etching rate than the
unirradiated fluorine PTR glass. So, the fluorine PTR
glass can be compared with well known
photoceramics of Foturan
TM
(Schott, Germany),
Fotoform
TM
(Corning, USA) and PEG3
TM
(Hoya,
Japan) with etching rates of 15-20 between the
crystalline phase and the glass host, that are
successfully used for fabrication of 3D hollow
microstructures, microfluidic devices, micro-total
analysis systems (μTAS), micro-electro-mechanical
systems (MEMS) and micro-opto-electro-mechanical
systems (MOEMS). At the same time holographic
properties of the Foturan
TM
and PEG3
TM
(Kösters et
al., 2005) greatly concede ones of the PTR glass.
To demonstrate photostructable properties of the
PTR glass the Russian abbreviation of the ITMO
University was chemically etched.
Figure 5: UV irradiated through mask and heat treated 1
mm PTR glass (A). Subsequently chemically etched PTR
glass (B).
Moreover, combination of photoetchable and ion
exchangeable properties of the PTR glass could open
new prospects for developing new microfluidic and
plasmonic devices. It’s well known that first
application of the ion exchange technology was a
glass strengthening (Nordberg et al., 1964). In
(Razzaghi et al., 2013) was shown that silver ion
exchange also can impart the hydrophobic properties
to glass surface. So it’s possible to improve chemical
durability, microhardness and hydrophilicity of
microfluidic channels formed in the PTR glass
Design and Fabrication of Optical Devices based on New Polyfunctional Photo-thermo-refractive Glasses
23
substrate. Besides that, silver ions in the ion
exchange layer can be transformed into either
luminescent silver molecular clusters or plasmonic
silver nanoparticles that allows developing integrated
microfluidic-plasmonic sensors.
For example, we realized luminescent clusters and
plasmonic nanoparticles inside of the hollow
structures in volume of the PTR glass by ion
exchange of Na
+
(glass)
Ag
+
(salt)
and following
thermal treatment.
Figure 6: Luminescent silver clusters (A) and plasmonic
silver nanoparticles (B) formed by silver ion exchange and
subsequent heat treatment inside of the hollow structures in
volume of the fluorine PTR glass.
2.5 Phosphors for LEDs and
Down-converters for Solar Cells
Luminescent silver molecular clusters and
complicated complexes like “silver-bromine” or
“silver-chlorine” can be precipitated in the PTR
glasses by using ion-exchange technique or can be
embedded in glass host during glass synthesis. These
clusters and complexes have a broadband
luminescence in the visible and NIR ranges under
UV) excitation (Dubrovin et al., 2014).
In the same time luminescent properties of the
PTR glasses have a strong dependence on glass
composition and treatments (UV irradiation, heat
treatment) parameters (Fig. 7).
Figure 7: Chlorine PTR glass samples and effects caused by
their treatment. (1) virgin glass, (2) UV irradiated glass, (3)
sample after the UV irradiation and heat treatment at T =
400°C for 3 h and (4) sample after the UV irradiation and
heat treatment at T = 500°C for 3h. Excitation wavelength
is 360nm.
An increase in luminescence intensity of the PTR
glass after UV irradiation is caused by transform of
silver ions Ag
+
, and charged molecular clusters Ag
n
+m
to neutral state during UV irradiation and also by
increasing neutral silver clusters number and size
during subsequent heat treatment. Formation of silver
nanoparticles results to decreasing luminescence
intensity. Absolute quantum yield of silver clusters
formed in bulk of PTR glass reaches 50%.
Figure 8: Luminescence spectra of heat treated at 400
o
C for
3h PTR glasses with silver clusters formed in the bulk (1)
and in ion exchanged layer (2), λ
ex
=360nm.
Thin layers with high concentration of
luminescent silver molecular clusters can be formed
by the silver ion exchange. Intensity, shape and
efficiency of the luminescence strongly depends on
the temperature and duration of subsequent heat
treatment. Luminescence efficiency grows with
increasing heat treatment temperature up to 450
o
C
that can be associated with increasing concentration
PHOTOPTICS 2016 - 4th International Conference on Photonics, Optics and Laser Technology
24
of silver molecular clusters. Heat treatment at
temperature higher than the glass transition
temperature (464
o
C) results to formation of silver
nanoparticles and luminescence quenching in the
visible. Concentration of reducing agents (Ce
3+
, Sb
3+
)
existing in the PTR glass also significantly effects on
the luminescence efficiency. Increasing CeO
2
or
Sb
2
O
3
concentration in the PTR glass composition
leads to luminescence quenching that can be caused
by the formation of larger clusters that have weak
luminescence in the visible and/or concentration
quenching. Ion exchanged PTR glasses with silver
molecular clusters reveal white light emission and
high absolute quantum yield (up to 63%).
As conclusion, the PTR glass can be successfully
used as phosphors for white LEDs or down-
converters for solar cells. It should be pointed out,
that these luminescent clusters and complexes can be
formed in defined local spot of the PTR glass
substrate by laser radiation. It allowed us to create
complicated light architecture from luminescent
centers.
Figure 9: Dependence of absolute quantum yield on the
antimony oxide concentration in PTR glass composition
and temperature of heat treatment.
2.6 Media for Optical Information
Storage
The bright luminescence of neutral silver molecular
clusters in PTR glasses makes possible to record
optical information in them by UV nanosecond laser
irradiation. If the PTR glass was preliminary
irradiated by the UV radiation into the absorption
band of Ce
3+
ions the UV nanosecond laser irradiation
results in the silver clusters luminescence quenching
(Fig. 10A). If the PTR glass was not preliminary
irradiated by the UV radiation into the absorption
band of Ce
3+
ions the UV nanosecond laser irradiation
results in the neutral silver clusters luminescence
appearance (Fig. 10B). The subsequent thermal
treatment above the glass transition temperature
results in the silver nanoparticles growth in the
irradiated zones. The described effects can be used for
the optical information recording by the local change
of glass luminescence or absorption.
Figure 10: Negative and positive luminescent images in
PTR glass plates irradiated through the mask by the UV
nanosecond laser radiation with (A) and without (B) the
preliminary irradiation by the UV mercury lamp.
2.7 Luminescent Thermo-sensors
PTR glasses can be successfully use for fabrication of
luminescent thermo-sensors. The effect of
temperature on the luminescence of neutral MC in
PTR glasses is illustrated in Fig. 11. As seen, the
shape and location of the luminescence maximum on
the wavelength scale remain intact under an increase
in temperature (Fig. 11A), whereas the intensity of
luminescence decreases. In particular, an increase in
temperature from -10 to +250
o
C causes a decrease in
the integrated intensity of luminescence by a factor of
25. Notably, the temperature dependence of the
luminescence intensity shows no hysteresis and can
be multiply reproduced. Such properties of PTR
glasses make them promising materials for the
luminescent temperature sensors. The temperature
dependence of luminescence intensity of PTR glass in
-10 - +250
O
C temperature range can be approximated
quite satisfactorily (see Fig. B) by empirical function
as follows:
I=0.9(0.55*exp(-T/25))+0.25*exp(-T/150) (1)
the former term being responsible for the low-
temperature section of the dependence and the latter
term for the high-temperature one. Complex nature of
the function is associated with the presence of several
types of MC in a glass.
Design and Fabrication of Optical Devices based on New Polyfunctional Photo-thermo-refractive Glasses
25
Figure 11: The effect of temperature on the luminescence
of PTR glass subjected to the UV irradiation and
subsequent heat treatment. A: The luminescence spectra
recorded at temperatures of (1) -10
O
C, (2) +25
O
C and (3)
+200
O
C. B: Normalized dependence of the integrated
intensity of luminescence on temperature.
Also the fluorine PTR glasses doped with rare
earth ions (for example, Er
3+
) can be used for
fabrication of luminescent thermo-sensors operating
in a wide temperature range (from - 200
o
C up to
+500
o
C). In this case, several effects can be used for
measurement of temperature: (i) temperature
dependence of erbium luminescence life time, (ii)
temperature deformation of profile of luminescence
spectra, and (iii) change of luminescence peaks of
thermo-coupling levels.
2.8 Plasmonic Sensors
Some technologies of control of concentration, size
and shape of silver metallic nanoparticles in bulk of
the PTR glass and on its surface (Fig. 12) have been
developed for plasmonic sensors. The technologies
allowed us to precipitate high concentration of silver
nanoparticles with size of 4-8 nm in the PTR glass
host. The absorption coefficient of the plasmonic pick
achieves more than 1000 cm
-1
. These silver
nanoparticles can have different shape: spherical,
ellipsoidal and cubical. These metallic particles can
be covered by dielectric (NaF) or semiconductor
(AgCl, AgBr) shells. Some applications of the
material have been demonstrated: chemical and
biological sensors based on localized surface plasmon
resonance.
Figure 12: AFM-image of silver nanoparticles on surface of
the PTR glass.
Figure 13: Spectral position of the plasmon resonance peaks
for the silver nanoparticles with (a) and without (b)
dielectric shell on a PTR glass surface in air (1) and in water
(2).
PHOTOPTICS 2016 - 4th International Conference on Photonics, Optics and Laser Technology
26
Silver nanoparticles can be formed on the surface
of PTR glasses by the thermal treatment in the
reducing atmosphere or by the laser ablation of the
surface of PTR glass. In the last case silver
nanoparticles are covered by the SiO
2
shell 3-5 nm
thick. Figure 13 shows the spectral position of the
plasmon resonance peaks for the silver nanoparticles
with (a) and without (b) dielectric shell on a PTR
glass surface in air and in water. In the first case the
plasmon resonance spectral shift is 6 nm, in the
second case – 13 nm. It is enough for the application
in the sensors for the environment refraction index
measurements.
3 CONCLUSIONS
We have demonstrated some examples of design and
fabrication of optical, photonic and plasmonic
devices based on new fluorine, chlorine and bromine
PTR glasses: holographic volume Bragg gratings for
diode lasers, optical amplifier, optical and plasmonic
waveguides, hollow structures, thermo- and
biosensors, phosphors for LEDs and down-converters
for solar cells.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
This work has been supported by the Ministry of
Education and Science of Russian Federation (Project
No.RFMEFI58114X0006).
REFERENCES
Aseev, V.A., Nikonorov, N.V., 2008. Spectroluminescence
properties of photothermorefractive nanoglass-
ceramics doped with ytterbium and erbium ions.
Journal of Optical Technology, 75(10), p.676.
Dubrovin, V., Ignatiev, A., Nevedomskii, V., Nikonorov,
N., Sidorov, A. & Tsekhomskii, V., 2014. The
influence of synthesis conditions and ultraviolet
irradiation on the morphology and concentration of
silver nanocrystals in photothermo-refractive glasses.
Glass Technology-European Journal of Glass Science
and Technology Part A, 55(6), pp.191–195.
Dubrovin, V.D., Ignatiev, A.I., Nikonorov, N. V., Sidorov,
A.I., Shakhverdov, T.A. & Agafonova, D.S., 2014.
Luminescence of silver molecular clusters in photo-
thermo-refractive glasses. Optical Materials, 36(4),
pp.753–759.
Efimov, A.M., Ignatiev, A.I., Nikonorov, N. V. &
Postnikov, E.S., 2011. Quantitative UV-VIS
spectroscopic studies of photo-thermo-refractive
glasses. I. Intrinsic, bromine-related, and impurity-
related UV absorption in photo-thermo-refractive glass
matrices. Journal of Non-Crystalline Solids, 357(19-
20), pp.3500–3512.
Glebova, L., Lumeau, J. & Glebov, L.B., 2011. Photo-
thermo-refractive glass co-doped with Nd 3+ as a new
laser medium. Optical Materials, 33(12), pp.1970–
1974.
Glebova, L., Lumeau, J., Klimov, M., Zanotto, E.D. &
Glebov, L.B., 2008. Role of bromine on the thermal and
optical properties of photo-thermo-refractive glass.
Journal of Non-Crystalline Solids, 354(2-9), pp.456–
461.
Hofmann, P., Amezcua-correa, R., Antonio-lopez, E., Ott,
D., Segall, M., Divliansky, I., Lumeau, J., Glebova, L.,
Glebov, L., Peyghambarian, N., et al., 2013. Strong
Bragg gratings in highly photosensitive photo-thermo-
refractive-glass optical fiber. IEEE Photonics
Technology Letters, 25(1), pp.25–28.
Kösters, M., Hsieh, H.-T., Psaltis, D. & Buse, K., 2005.
Holography in commercially available photoetchable
glasses. Applied optics, 44(17), pp.3399–3402.
Nikonorov, N., Aseev, V. & Ignatiev, A., 2010. New
polyfunctional photo-thermo-refractive glasses for
photonics applications. In ODF’10. pp. 209–210.
Nordberg, M.E., Mochel, E.L., Garfinkel, H.M. & Olcott,
J.S., 1964. Strengthening by Ion Exchange. Journal of
the American Ceramic Society, 47(5), pp.215–219.
Razzaghi, A., Maleki, M. & Azizian-Kalandaragh, Y.,
2013. The influence of post-annealing treatment on the
wettability of Ag+/Na+ ion-exchanged soda-lime
glasses. Applied Surface Science, 270, pp.604–610.
Design and Fabrication of Optical Devices based on New Polyfunctional Photo-thermo-refractive Glasses
27