A Comparison of Data and Process Mediation Approaches

Rodrigo Mantovaneli Pessoa, Dick Quartel, Marten van Sinderen


In recent years, a huge amount of effort has been invested in the area of service discovery and composition. However, surprisingly little effort is being put into the evaluation of these approaches. The SWS Challenge is an ongoing and continuous experiment in developing a common understanding of various technologies intended to facilitate the automation of mediation, composition, and discovery for Web Services using semantic annotations. The mediation scenario problems concern making a legacy order management system interoperable with external systems that use a simplified version of the RosettaNet PIP3A4 specifications. The participants are supposed to be evaluated with focus on functional coverage. However, it turned out that it is extremely difficult to assess this in an objective manner. In this paper, we describe a framework for comparison of data and process mediation approaches. As a case study, we apply our framework to perform a comparative analysis of four participants from the SWS Challenge.


  1. Petrie, C., Margaria, T., Käuster, U., Lausen, H., Zaremba, M. (2007): SWS Challenge: status, perspectives and lessons learned so far. In Proceedings of the 9th International Conference on Enterprise Information Systems (ICEIS2007), Special Session on Comparative Evaluation of Semantic Web Service Frameworks, Funchal, MadeiraPortugal.
  2. Kitchenham, B. (1996): DESMET: A method for evaluating Software Engineering methods and tools Technical Report TR96-09. Department of Computer Science, University of Keele, Staffordshire.
  3. M. Brambilla, I. Celino, S. Ceri, D. Cerizza, E. Della Valle, F. M. Facca (2006): A Software Engineering Approach to Design and Development of Semantic Web Service Applications, In Proceedings of the 5th International Semantic Web Conference (ISWC 2006), Athens, GA, USA, 5-9 November 2006, LNCS 4273, pp. 172-186.
  4. White S. A. (2004). Business Process Modeling Notation (BPMN), BPMI.org, http://www.bpmi.org/ bpmi-downloads/BPMN-V1.0.pdf
  5. S. Ceri, P. Fraternali, and M. Matera (2002): Conceptual Modeling of Data-Intensive web Applications. IEEE Internet Computing, 6(4).
  6. D. Roman, U. Keller, L. Lausen, J. de Bruijn, R. Lara, M. Stollberg, A. Polleres, C. Feier, C. Bussler, and D. Fensel (2005): Web Service Modeling Ontology, Applied Ontologies, vol. 1, pp. 77-106.
  7. Mocan, A., Moran, M., Cimpian, E., and Zaremba, M. (2006): Filling the gap - extending service oriented architectures with semantics. In ICEBE, pp. 594-601. IEEE Computer Society.”
  8. de Bruijn, J. , H. Lausen, A. Polleres, D. Fensel (2006) The Web Service Modeling Language WSML: An Overview. In Proceedings of the 3rd European Semantic Web Conference (ESWC 2006), Budva, Montenegro: Springer, LNCS 4011.
  9. Steffen, B., Margaria, T., Nagel, R., Jörges, S., and Kubczak, C. (2006). Model-Driven Development with the jABC. In Proceedings of Haifa Verification Conference, LNCS N.4383. Springer Verlag.
  10. Müller-Olm, M., Schmidt, D., and Steffen, B. (1999). Model-checking: A tutorial introduction. In SAS, 6th In: Static Analysis Symposium, LNCS N.1694, pages 330-354. Springer Verlag.
  11. Dick A. Quartel , Maarten W. Steen , Stanislav Pokraev , Marten J. Sinderen (2007): COSMO: A conceptual framework for service modelling and refinement, Information Systems Frontiers, v.9 n.2-3, p.225-244.

Paper Citation

in Harvard Style

Pessoa R., Quartel D. and van Sinderen M. (2008). A Comparison of Data and Process Mediation Approaches . In Proceedings of the 2nd International Workshop on Enterprise Systems and Technology - Volume 1: I-WEST, ISBN 978-989-8111-50-0, pages 48-63. DOI: 10.5220/0004464800480063

in Bibtex Style

author={Rodrigo Mantovaneli Pessoa and Dick Quartel and Marten van Sinderen},
title={A Comparison of Data and Process Mediation Approaches},
booktitle={Proceedings of the 2nd International Workshop on Enterprise Systems and Technology - Volume 1: I-WEST,},

in EndNote Style

JO - Proceedings of the 2nd International Workshop on Enterprise Systems and Technology - Volume 1: I-WEST,
TI - A Comparison of Data and Process Mediation Approaches
SN - 978-989-8111-50-0
AU - Pessoa R.
AU - Quartel D.
AU - van Sinderen M.
PY - 2008
SP - 48
EP - 63
DO - 10.5220/0004464800480063